NYC’s Capital Debt and Real Estate Valuation (FY2025)

The NYC Comptroller’s Annual Report on Capital Debt and Obligations for Fiscal Year 2025 provides an important update on the city’s debt management and its implications for property owners. As the city addresses infrastructure demands and fiscal constraints, understanding how real estate valuations influence property taxes and borrowing power is essential.

NYC’s Debt Limit and Real Estate Valuation

The city’s ability to borrow for infrastructure projects depends on its constitutional debt limit, set at 10% of the five-year average full valuation of taxable real estate. This valuation is calculated using Special Equalization Ratios (SERs), which adjust assessed values to approximate market values. However, these ratios often underestimate true market values, particularly for co-ops and condos, which are valued based on rental income rather than sales prices.

This undervaluation has two major implications:

1. Constrained Borrowing Power: The FY2025 report projects that the city’s debt-incurring power will decline from $41 billion at the start of FY2025 to $33.2 billion by FY2028, with further reductions expected in subsequent years. This limits the city’s ability to fully utilize its real estate base for borrowing.
2. Increased Pressure on Property Tax Assessments: To offset borrowing constraints, the city may rely on property tax increases or aggressive assessments, directly affecting property owners.

Debt Service and Fiscal Management

Debt service—the annual payments on the city’s borrowing—remains a central concern. NYC uses a 15% debt service-to-tax revenue ratio as a benchmark for affordability. While the FY2025 report indicates that this ratio will stay below the threshold, rising capital commitments could push it closer in coming years.

The Comptroller has recommended formalizing this benchmark into policy by incorporating measures such as prepaying debt service through reserves. This would help the city manage fiscal pressures while maintaining its ability to fund necessary infrastructure projects.

Why Property Owners Should Care

The FY2025 report highlights how closely real estate valuation and fiscal policy are connected. For property owners, this connection means:

• Valuation Accuracy is Essential: Undervaluation in SER calculations not only affects the city’s borrowing capacity but can result in inequities in tax burdens.
• Assessment Scrutiny is Necessary: As fiscal pressures grow, property owners may face higher tax assessments. Ensuring fair valuations is important to protecting your financial interests.

The Role of Property Tax Professionals

Navigating property tax assessments and appeals can be complex. A property tax professional can:

• Identify errors or inconsistencies in valuations.
• Advocate for adjustments based on accurate market data.

Final Thoughts

The FY2025 report demonstrates the relationship between NYC’s real estate valuations, property taxes, and debt management. As the city seeks to balance infrastructure needs with fiscal stability, property owners must remain informed. Hiring a property tax professional is an effective way to ensure fair assessments and safeguard against unnecessary tax increases.

Property taxes are more than just a financial obligation—they reflect the city’s broader fiscal strategies. Staying engaged and prepared is essential for navigating these challenges.

---

Read more at: Annual Report on Capital Debt and Obligations, Fiscal Year 2025: Office of the New York City Comptroller Brad Lander