Skip to main content

Industry Updates

DHCR Updates Fact Sheet #40 Regarding Rent Concessions / Net Effective Rents

DHCR Updates Fact Sheet #40 Regarding Rent Concessions / Net Effective Rents

Published 11/16/2026 at 5:00 PM

By: Deborah E. Riegel & Zachary J. Rothken

In April 2026, we notified you of the decision issued by the Appellate Division, First Department in Grey v. LIC Dev. Owner, L.P., in which the Court held that post-HSTPA rent concessions are the functional equivalent of preferential rents. The primary rationale for the decision was the removal of the distinction between rent concessions and preferential rents, previously found in DHCR Fact Sheet #40, which the Court found signified a change in DHCR policy.

Today, DHCR updated Fact Sheet #40 with a new section on Rent Concessions, which restores the prior distinction. The Grey decision has driven a renewed wave of overcharge litigation as to whether a temporary rent concession equates to a preferential rent that must be continued until a vacancy.

Before the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA), Fact Sheet #40 defined two kinds of rent relief:

  1. One-time concessions tied to specific months.
  2. Preferential Rents, which reduced the monthly rent in each month of the term.

When DHCR revised the fact sheet after HSTPA in 2019, it eliminated that distinction and was silent on the issue, which the Appellate Division, First Department has read as a change in DHCR’s policy.

In its updated Fact Sheet #40, DHCR now states plainly that it was never DHCR’s intention to change its policy and the distinction between concessions and preferential rents has always remained intact. The updated Fact Sheet #40 makes clear that concessions are still recognized. Specifically, DHCR states that it “continues to recognize that there are distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents,” and its 2019 modification “was not intended to indicate the contrary.

The updated Fact Sheet #40 is not a blanket approval of all concessions. Whether an agreement is a true concession depends on the specific facts and circumstances presented at the time of the agreement. These may include, but are not limited to:

  1. the circumstances giving rise to the abatement, including physical conditions affecting the property or other circumstances affecting residential occupancy;
  2. the duration and temporary nature of the abatement; and
  3. the actual language of the agreement.

Given that DHCR’s policy is to view post-HSTPA rent concessions as factual inquiries on a case-by-case basis, we encourage you to reach out to Zachary Rothken or Deborah Riegel, who authored this alert, or your trusted R&E attorney to discuss best practices for your portfolio and potential litigation defense.